Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
A question for the physics brains out there.
Collapse
X
-
arveejay
A question for the physics brains out there.
Yeah maybe I've got too much time on my hands but here goes. I just aquired a wheelchair lift from an old handicap van. It is rated at 1500 pounds. It is about 50 inches long and the average street bike needs about 85 inches of base to sit on. I have it raised off the ground 2 feet, bolted it to the floor and cabled it to a main support beam, this will give me 2 feet of lift, but I need to add about 3 feet of base so I can roll a bike on and lift it up which will make for easier working. My question is by adding 3 feet of deck and moving the center of gravity back won't a 500 pound bike feel like it is much heavier being farther from the lifting point. It lifts the whole setup from the end so all the weight is concentrated on the end of the lifting mechanism. From what I remember from school the farther the weight is from the lifting point, the heavier the work load. Will doubling the lifting base and stretching out the weight, won't the 500 pounds feel more like 1000 pounds? Am I waisting my time only to find out it won't work. Any thoughts?Tags: None
-
Dink
-
arveejay
Dink, the whole thing bolts to the wall and raises in on itself so it cant be centered. I thought about making it enter sideways with the base sitting sideways. That would keep the weight close but wouldn't allow working on the side up agains the frame.
Comment
-
Forum LongTimerCharter Member
GSResource Superstar
Past Site Supporter- May 2002
- 19275
- Toronto, Canada
Fully agree with Dink. Simple solution, too.
You might try making the extensions fold when not in use...weld full width steel plates from the original base so that the extension, when lowered, rests on the the plates and will not permit flex. Alternatively, weld at least two pieces of black gas pipe on each end of the original plate and then on the extensions. Mount them close to the edge to minimize flex and make them at least six inches in length.
Use 1/2 inch bolts or larger, or steel bar stock to hold them in place. If using 1/2 inch supports, you should use three supports on each end of the plate. The support bars should fit the pipe fairly closely, not snug, but just loose enough to allow sliding movement. Drill the rods and use roll pins on each end to secure them, once in place.Bertrand Russell: 'Men are born ignorant, not stupid. They are made stupid by education.'
Comment
-
Anonymous
I would think that it all depends on what is the mechanical constraint producing the 1500 lb. lift limit. The efective weight limit (vertical component) wouldn't change. What will change is the effective torque applied to the lifting base, where the lifting base attaches to the lifting mechanism, or to any attachment points to which that torque is transmitted.
Comment
-
Anonymous
Simon, I agree. Adding additional length will increase the torque applied to the lifting mechanism. Without knowing how lift is created it is difficult to provide any suggestions. Do you have any pictures you can post?
Comment
-
HiSPL
Is it possible to get the bike on the center stand on the deck space you have now? If so just forget the extra real estate and let the wheel hang off. your bike will be solidly supported by the center stand and which ever wheel is on the lift. For extra safety you could tie down the wheel thats on the lift with ratchet straps. This would also allow you to strap down the rear to raise front wheel off the ground.
BTW this sounds like an excellent DIY project, I've been racking my brain to figure out how to build a bike lift at home without spending mega bucks......
Please post some pics....
Comment
-
focus frenzy
Originally posted by HiSPL
BTW this sounds like an excellent DIY project, I've been racking my brain to figure out how to build a bike lift at home without spending mega bucks.....
here it is, http://www.harborfreight.com/cpi/cta...temnumber=2792
Comment
-
Jay B
Originally posted by HiSPLIs it possible to get the bike on the center stand on the deck space you have now? If so just forget the extra real estate and let the wheel hang off. your bike will be solidly supported by the center stand and which ever wheel is on the lift. For extra safety you could tie down the wheel thats on the lift with ratchet straps. This would also allow you to strap down the rear to raise front wheel off the ground.
BTW this sounds like an excellent DIY project, I've been racking my brain to figure out how to build a bike lift at home without spending mega bucks......
Please post some pics....
Comment
-
arveejay
Lots of good thoughts out there. I can take a picture but I don't know how to get it here. I'll try some of the suggestions and see what happens. Thanks again.
Comment
-
Anonymous
Id try it...... i dont think extending it 3 feet will mattter that much. IF you have all the weight on that last 3 feet , MAYBE it would be an issue. but since you have a 500 pound bike spread out over that whole distance,,,, wich originally could handle a 1500 pound bike, i dont thikn its going to matter and i thiink it will serve its purpose well.
but you got to watch out for them thinkers!
Comment
-
Dark Jedi
Well, from what you describe you need to make it a reverse fulcrum.
Extend the lifting arm a bit, but leave the current lift point where it is. That way you gain the leverage of a longer lift arm for the same lift distance.
Old:
------------^
|
|
New:
------------^---------
|
|
Does that make any sense whatsoever? It's hard to describe without a decent picture.
Comment
-
Anonymous
By extending the lift three feet you increase the moment acting on the rigid mounting point. What I would do is increase your base by your three feet and make more then one rigid mounting point. Support the base towards the the top of the "wall" with some bracing. The lift can handle it, its a matter of if your connecting point can handle the downward force without shearing off. I built a lift out of hydraulic cylinders and some channel to support the bike. i had it all mounted on the side of a barn wall. the base was 5ft long, with a tool tray near the wall. I should have taken pics of it. The guy moved.....don't know who lives there now. I don't even know if that lift is still in the barn!
Comment
-
arveejay
I will describe it as best as I can. The thing sat at the back of a van. When it was in the van it was at it's raised point so it was actually mounted at the height of a big van. When the lift was letting someone out it was letting gravity pull it down at a controled slow speed. When it lifted up the pump has to withdraw the cylinder and pull it up. The frame bed is big enough for a wheelchair and thats about it. The lift has a frame work over it and still allows a wheelchair to pass thru it. The frame I made is 2 feet high and made out of square tubing, it is the same size as the base of the unit. It is bolted to the frame and the frame is anchored to the floor and the wall, that is why I can't go closer to the center, heck because of the lifting frame work I cant even use the first foot of the base as it would be too high for the bike to go in, although I could move it forward once I goy it lifted but that makes me a little nervous.once I also have a cable attached to the unit and thru the wall to a frame post in the shed behind the garage. The frame work is what worries me. There is an iron rectangularly shaped 4 sided channel that slides into a bigger channel of the same shape. There is a nylon button on the outer channel where the weight slides, There is one of these per side. Since I have it 2 feet off of the ground I only have 2 feet of lift so that part doesnt really scare me. Picture it sideways, its shaped about like a 4 feet high 4 feet long 110 degree shape. All the force is on the corner of the brace, and it doesn't really look that impressive. Add to that extending it and doubling the pressure or more had me wondering if I was looking for trouble. I'm probably going to make supports for the corners and reinforce there.That's my quandry. I have not tried rolling it on and putting it on the center stand and let it hang. I like that but had not even thought of it yet myself. I will try that as soon as I add to the support frame work as I'm still not confident.
Comment
-
arveejay
Allright, the base is not long enough to put the bike on the center stand. Here's what I'm going to do. I'm going to buy 7 ft channel iron, bend the front for the bike to sit against, bolt it to the table and then roll the bike on, tie it down, and raise it up. I'll work on it this weekend and try to post a pic. I got to reinforce a little first then try it. I'll let you know. Thanks for all the ideas. You guys never fail to come up with ideas.
Comment
Comment